[Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Thread Index] [Date Prev] [Date Next] [Date Index]

Re: paleonet Discussion: Anglo-Saxon Science versus the rest of the world



Dear Paleonetters,

 

There is no doubt that non-English speakers have a hard time being acknowledged outside their language group if they only published in their own language, but this marginalisation is not intentional, although the tenor of Dr Crow’s message gives the impression that it is. It is just how things are at present largely because of the former extent of the British Empire and the initial development of personal computers in the English speaking world. I suspect that Non-German and non-Latin speakers had a similar problem in times past. Maybe another language (Mandarin, Arabic, Hindi?) will take over in the future after the decline and fall of the current English-speaking empires.

 

I have attempted to deal with publications in my fields of expertise in other languages by learning these languages to a degree where I can translate the bits I need. It is not easy, but it hopefully makes my science better if I can deal with all the relevant publications, rather than just those in my own language. I know that many workers in my bailiwick do not even bother, and the pandemic nature of the organisms concerned lead them to commit the occasional howler.

 

Hopefully, in the future it will not matter which language you publish in, as expert systems will be able to translate the text immediately. By that time I’ll probably be dribbling down my shirt;-)

 

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Dr John R. Laurie

Eastern and Onshore Petroleum

GEOSCIENCE AUSTRALIA
GPO Box 378        
Canberra
ACT 2601      
Australia
             
Tel: (02) 6249 9412; Fax: (02) 6249 9980
E-mail: John.Laurie@ga.gov.au

Street Address:
Cnr Jerrabomberra Avenue & Hindmarsh Drive
Symonston ACT 2609

ABN 80 091 799 039
-----------------------------------------------------------------