[Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Thread Index] [Date Prev] [Date Next] [Date Index]

Re: paleonet question marks in taxonomic names



Dear Bjorn
Here's my version:
?Agenus aspecies  -genus assignment doubtful
Agenus ?aspecies  -species assignment doubtful
?Agenus ?aspecies  -both genus and species assignment doubtful.
I do it this way for two reasons: 1- placement of question marks is consistent
with placement of cf and aff designations; 2- there is no possibility that the
containing sentence could be misconstrued as a question.
Best
Pierre
_______________________________
Dr PD Kruse
Northern Territory Geological Survey
PO Box 3000
Darwin NT 0801 Australia
Tel: (8) 8999 5451  Fax: (8) 8999 6824
Web: http://www.minerals.nt.gov.au/ntgs


                                                                       
             björn kröger                                          
             <bjoekroe@gmx.de>                                         
             Sent by:                                                        To
             paleonet-owner@nhm.         Paleonet@nhm.ac.uk            
             ac.uk                                                           cc
                                                                       
                                                                        Subject
             01/09/2006 07:54 PM         paleonet question marks in taxonomic
                                         names                         
                                                                       
              Please respond to                                        
             paleonet@nhm.ac.uk                                        
                                                                       
                                                                       
                                                                       




Dear colleagues,

when the status of a taxon, or the taxonomic position of a specimen
is not clear in some taxonomic papers the taxa contain question marks
at different positions, such as:

?Michelinoceras michelini (Barrande, 1866)
Michelinoceras? michelini (Barrande, 1866)
Michelinoceras ?michelini (Barrande, 1866)
Michelinoceras michelini? (Barrande, 1866)

I guess, every position has a different meaning and the position is
regulated by a rule of the ICZN.
However, where can I find this rule and where is written what the the
meaning of each specific position of the question mark is?

Any information is appreciated

Bjoern



----------------------
Dr. Björn Kröger
Museum für Naturkunde
an der Humboldt Universität Berlin
Invalidenstr. 43
D-10115 Berlin
Germany