[Thread Prev] | [Thread Next] | [Thread Index] | [Date Prev] | [Date Next] | [Date Index] |
Dear Norm, What did I ever do to you Norm? Don't answer that. I suppose the Schram is Fred Schram? Iguess I will have to go dig out a copy of the paper,but I can't imagine what unusual isotopes of common elements they mean. More to the point however, I cosmic ray bombardment should leave relatively obvious differences in extinction-survival patterns. For starters, shallow-water forms should be more heavily affected than deeper-water marine taxa, and terrestrial stuff more than marine (cosmic rays don't penetrate very far into water). It is true that fusulinids were evidently in shallower water than other forams and suffered heavier extinction, but if you look at other groups there is no evidence that I can think of in favor of this pattern, and (positive evidence coming up here folks, just to make Stormin' Norman happy) considerable evidence against. I don't suppose the guys who wrote this bothered to attempt to test it at all against the fossil record, did they norm? Doug Erwin
Partial index: