[Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Thread Index] [Date Prev] [Date Next] [Date Index]

Re: paleonet 10 Questions to Ask Your Biology Teacher



I think you have answered your own question.  Badly
prepared and educated "teachers" who don't know the answers
to these questions.
--- Bill Chaisson/Deirdre Cunningham <chaisson@netacc.net>
wrote:
> >A Gallup poll late last year showed that only 28 percent
> of
> >Americans accept the theory of evolution, while 48
> percent adhere to
> >creationism - the belief that an intelligent being is
> responsible for the
> >creation of the earth and its inhabitants. But if
> reluctance to accept
> >evolution is not new, the ways in which students are
> resisting its teachings
> >are changing.
> 
> Excuse me, but when will a significant and 
> influential contingent of the education community 
> admit that the simplest explanation for this 
> statistic is that evolution is taught poorly in 
> public schools.
> 
> >It creates an uncomfortable atmosphere in the 
> >classroom, Williamson says - one that he doesn't 
> >like. "I don't want to ever be in a 
> >confrontational mode with those kids ... I find 
> >it disheartening as a teacher."
> 
> Wow.  A teacher who resists and avoids a spirited 
> (pun intended) dialog with students.  Great.
> 
> 
> >In this climate, science teachers say they must find new
> methods to defuse
> >what has become a politically and emotionally charged
> atmosphere in the
> >classroom. But in some cases doing so also means
> learning to handle
> >well-organized efforts to raise doubts about Darwin's
> theory.
> 
> Defuse?
> 
> When students bring racial prejudice into the 
> classroom, do teachers simply complain about 
> having to deal with the issue, or do they try, 
> through their curriculum, to do something about 
> it?
> 
> >Critics of evolution are supplying students with
> prepared questions on such
> >topics as:
> >• The origins of life. Why do textbooks claim that the
> 1953 Miller-Urey
> >experiment shows how life's building blocks may have
> formed on Earth - when
> >conditions on the early Earth were probably nothing like
> those used in the
> >experiment, and the origin of life remains a mystery?
> 
> Most of these questions are bona fide sources of 
> confusion.  In some cases the questions are 
> caused by a misunderstanding of scientific 
> statement .  At least one simply exposes some 
> hanky panky that is embarrassing and 
> understandably sabotaged the credibility of the 
> conclusions (peppered moths).
> 
> Given the easy access of enormous amounts of 
> information today, why can't these questions be 
> addressed in a classroom?
> 
> Bill
> --
> ---------------------------------------------------
> William P. Chaisson
> Adjunct Assistant Professor
> Department of Earth and Environmental Sciences
> University of Rochester
> Rochester, NY  14627
> 607-387-3892
> 
> 

"The United States is in no sense founded upon the Christian religion." - George Washington

__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com