[Thread Prev] [Thread Next] [Thread Index] [Date Prev] [Date Next] [Date Index]

Re: paleonet Newfoundland and Labrador Fossil Protection Legislation




In a message dated 12/6/01 9:39:24 AM Pacific Standard Time, arindsberg@gsa.state.al.us writes:

Pristis@aol.com wrote,
'It is easy to be lulled into a sense that Canadians are "just like us" with
the same values.  Then something like this proposed legislation comes to
light.  It seems that Canadians don't have the same private property rights
that we do!'

arindsburg@gsa.state.al.us wrote:
<snip humor>
Actually, with fifty state legal codes in the USA, almost anything is
possible. Decades ago, Alabama's Antiquities Act made it illegal for anyone
but Alabama archaeologists (or those working with them) to excavate
artefacts, and this includes private property owners. Potsherds, arrowheads,
and other artefacts may be collected legally from the surface. As best as I
can tell, buried artefacts may be privately owned but not collected in
Alabama, whereas the proposal in Newfoundland is to declare fossils as
public property.

Although the Alabama law has proved difficult to enforce, it has probably
prevented some damage from occurring just by being on the books.
Unfortunately, the Act does not apply to fossils, which are currently
unprotected except (like anything else found on private or state-owned land)
by property laws.

Andrew K. Rindsberg

So, you think that it is "unfortunate" that fossils on private land do not belong to the State of Alabama, that Alabama fossils in private hands should be contraband to be forfeited or seized by state agents.  You imagine that the body of private property law has somehow overlooked the greater good: the State's should assert title to fossils in any and every citizen's backyard.  Fossils are more important than the property rights of individuals.  You really believe that?  

I think you'll wait a long time for this property rights "problem" to be corrected in Alabama.  LOL  As an agent of the State of Alabama, are you speaking for the governor of Alabama?  Someone should pass on to him your post.  Maybe there is a job-opening in Labrador.   :^)

----Harry Pristis